Any people, places, names, products or events mentioned are done so without permission or endorsement, this is a work of fiction.
My name is Jesse and I am 21 years old, 5' 11" with a good body, short black hair, and a genius IQ. I am usually the smartest person in the room, but unlike Sheldon, I'm not rude, sarcastic or anti-social. Usually I keep to myself because my mom says I'm a conundrum. I have the looks and body of an athlete, but have zero interest in or understanding of sports... or people. I prefer videogames, Star Trek and any kind of police or detective shows. I play games on my phone, on my tablet, on my Steam Deck, my Xbox and even on my smart TV. I breezed through high school and the same so far with college, but that left me with a small circle of friends and still a virgin at 21. As far as I know, only my mom knows and she certainly isn't going to say anything, so I just change the subject or pretend I've had sex when anyone asks. I had a girlfriend named Katie in high school, but she was quiet and shy like me, so for the entire year we went out we never did more than kiss and cuddle a whole lot.
My life turned upside down this semester when our dorm changed policies and for some reason everything was jumbled and changed. My roommate for the last two semesters was put in a different room and I was given a football player who liked to party ALL THE TIME. I tried everything to get him moved or to switch rooms myself, but to no avail. I was literally considering quitting after the third day with no sleep and drunk idiots all around me when I saw a posting on the bulletin board. A roommate was needed immediately but the catch was it was a house off campus. I'm used to being on campus from Fall until Spring so it was unsettling to consider having a commute and having to cook and clean and whatever else. Still, drunk jocks were NOT my things so I went to the address after class. I almost died when she answered the door. A stunningly beautiful blonde wearing nothing but skimpy pink thong panties and a small sleeveless half t-shirt that barely covered huge breasts. I could see half her underboob, almost the same amount of sideboob, and her nipples were practically poking through the pointless shirt.
She introduced herself as Danielle, said she preferred Dani, and is 21 years old, 6' tall with long blonde hair, a stacked, fit, athletic body with perfect curves and delicious tan skin. She blurted that she was a cheerleader, ran track and played lacrosse as if she thought I cared about any of it. A few sentences into talking and I realized Dani was dumber than a box of rocks and hotter than a Summer breeze. She said her girlfriend Lexi would be home soon and then we could decide what room I got. I was confused. Girlfriend? What room I got? Just like that I became the roommate? I think what really confused me was that Dani was hotter than fire and came across as easier than an open book test, so why did she have a girlfriend? Dani was fussing all around me, touched me 30 or 40 times, flirted up a storm, she didn't care that her body was 80 or 90 percent exposed, and I was rock hard while praying she didn't notice. I tried to redirect her several times and barely found out that the house was her grandmother's and that their roommate had gotten married and moved out last week. I have never had a female pay this much attention to me and it was both intoxicating and arousing. I tried to focus but fully dressed Dani would be a handful. Pretty much naked she was like a roaring campfire.
The front door slammed and a tall, gorgeous dark haired girl came in, smiled at me, then embraced Dani in one of the hottest kisses I have ever seen anywhere, including the internet! Dani said "This is my girlfriend Lexi" and Lexi blushed then said "Stop telling people that babe, it confuses them". Then she took my hand, smiled, and said "Hi, I'm Alexandria but you can just call me Lexi. Everyone does". Was it possible to get harder than rock hard? I did! Lexi is 21 years old, 5' 11"' tall with long black hair, an extremely athletic, fit and toned body, and she bragged later that she was not only a cheerleader but played volleyball. From what I gathered, Lexi wasn't an airhead like Dani, but she was not the brightest bulb as you are about to find out. Dani was still crowding me, hovering and flirting as Lexi asked "Are you Dani's new boyfriend?" I gasped but Dani said "No silly, we get to share him, he's our new roommate". I didn't have the breath to gasp again so I stood there quietly as Lexi said "Oh, okay, but share means share Dani. I'm going to be mad if he's always with you. I hardly got to spend any time with Dave". WHAT? Did I mention Lexi was wearing a blue micro skirt, tight white crop top, and clearly no bra? Yeah!
The next thing I knew Lexi was holding my hand and showing me around the house. It was a nice house, older build, all one level with a full basement that was mostly used for storage. Four bedrooms were literally next to and across from each other, with a fifth slightly down the hall that the girls had turned into a study office with two desks and such. Both bathrooms were not in or attached to a bedroom and the kitchen was nice with all new appliances. There was a dining room, the large living room, and a nice fenced backyard with an in-ground pool. If I was to be the third roommate, who was going to be in the fourth bedroom? Wow, the house was nice. I have no idea where Dani went, but Lexi was still holding my hand and had taken over all flirting duties. I'm not kidding that I was rock hard, nearly dizzy, and thinking thoughts I had never before thought. Lexi led me to a very clean, clearly vacant bedroom and said "This is yours babe". I asked "Babe?" Lexi poured herself against me and kissed me warmly but jumped back as if I had electrocuted her. She boldly touched the bulge in my pants with her fingertip then asked blushing "Did I... is that...uh... from me?" I swallowed but that was my mistake as Lexi zeroed in and asked "Wait a minute. Are you a virgin?" I blushed bright red and laughed "What? No" but Lexi glanced over her shoulder at the open door, then stared into my eyes and asked "Are you lying?"
I collapsed on the bed and Lexi literally sat on my lap, wriggled to get comfortable with my trapped cock ramming her, then asked quietly "Are you?" I exhaled then said "You'll just make fun of me and..." suddenly Lexi's tongue was in my mouth and her body was completely atop mine. My hands found her ass and it spurred her desire as if she had been electrocuted. Over a year with Katie and never even once did we make out like this. I was in all new territory and the water was very, very deep. Plus I have the sense that these sharks bite... often! Lexi was still kissing my breath away from me when Dani was suddenly pulling her off me saying "Babe... Lexi... hold on... calm down babe... listen..." Lexi was wild eyed as she panted "He's a virgin. He's mine". Dani blinked several times then said "That doesn't make sense. He's a hottie, how can he be a virgin?" I don't recall ever being referred to as a hottie but I was dizzy with arousal so who knew. Then the least possible expected thing occurred. Lexi and Dani left the room in full discussion of whose boyfriend I was. Two off the charts hot cheerleaders fighting to date me?
No one, including me, would ever believe a single part of this.
I sat up trying to ignore my raging erection and wondered if maybe I could just deal with the drunk jocks for a few more days. I was sure to find an apartment or roommate by then. There would certainly be less drama with the jocks. I went out into the living room and there is just no way to describe what I saw. Danielle was sitting on the floor drawing something illegible with crayons on a huge piece of paper. Crayons. Alexandria was using colored markers to do some kind of Canadian math on the whiteboard attached to the fridge. What in the actual fuck? Yeah, the jock was a better option. I took one last look at two of the hottest women I would ever see, then left. The upside of the whole disaster was later when the jock was out partying, I rubbed out one of my biggest eruptions thinking about Dani's sexy body and how great it felt to kiss Lexi. I'm sure most guys would have paid to be back there with Dani and Lexi, but I wanted to study and excel at life, not party all the time and get laid like the jocks and cheerleaders of this world. In a few years when I'm running a company, counting my money, and flying into space, they'll be taking your order or washing your car.
Okay, maybe I can be a little rude.
The next day I was in my Economics class when the professor stopped in mid lecture, took his glasses off, and asked "Can I help you young lady?" I turned to look like everyone else and froze. Alexandria. She was looking around the hall and a bad feeling told me she was looking for me. Of course she HAD to be wearing the cute college cheer uniform, her hair in a bouncy ponytail and a clueless smile on her face. I closed my eyes but it didn't matter as I heard "BABE" and wondered if I could still escape. Every eye was on me as the popular and beautiful cheerleader came over to me and shocked me with a wet kiss, an awkward standing hug, then she sat in the seat next to me and tried to snuggle. Why me? The professor asked "Friend of yours Mister Williams?" I opened my mouth to speak but Lexi blurted "Girlfriend" as if anyone could possibly believe that. I might have imagined it, but it felt like the entire hall burst into whispers and confusion as to how a nobody like me could possibly be with a somebody like Lexi. I whispered "Why are you doing this?" Lexi was all smiles as she purred "My plan was better than Dani's so you get to be mine".
Wow. Canadian math beat crayon scribble. Who knew?
Then Lexi whined "I have to share you with her, but mostly you'll be mine".
Was this really happening?
The professor crossed his arms and said loudly "Please take your time Mister Williams. You have us all intrigued at this point". I closed my laptop, shoved it in my backpack, and asked "Can I...?" The professor said "That would be best" then he smiled and said "Good luck with the sharing and all". The room burst into laughter and I just wanted to die. Of course Lexi was glued to me as I hurried out of the lecture hall and asked her "What is wrong with you?" Lexi sighed "Well, supposedly I don't think things through and I rely on my looks but I think I'm just a happy person so..." Lexi pouted "Oh..." then whined "Why are you being mean?" I broke my composure and held her as I said "I'm not trying to be mean. I just don't understand all this boyfriend and sharing nonsense". Lexi pulled away from me and stared at me confused. She blinked "You don't want to be with me?" I exhaled "I didn't say that Lexi. It's just... well... normally girls like you don't associate with guys like me". Lexi seemed confused so I exhaled and said "Associate means talk to, hang out with, date". She laughed "Oh. Well, I can date who I want to so there". I rubbed my face with my hand then asked "Is this some kind of prank?"
Lexi said "No" as if that answered all of my questions.
She took my hand and led me out of the building and said "So we have a surprise for you babe". Babe? I sighed and asked "You do?" She beamed "Yup. Come on, you'll see". I literally wasn't surprised that she had a pink Camry. What puzzled me was that I was fairly certain Toyota didn't normally produce pink vehicles. She drove like a maniac until she screeched to a stop in front of the house they were renting. I asked "Why are we here?" Lexi smiled "Because we're home silly". I said "I have other classes today Lex". She said "E" and I asked "What?" Lexi said "It's Lexi, not Lex" and I sighed "Right". Pretty much everything from the start with these cheerleaders defied normal logic, so imagine my surprise to find Dani, Mike (my football player roommate), three other cheerleaders and a couple more jocks all inside finishing moving my things in. The combined IQ in the room probably didn't equal 100 but they moved all of my stuff on me while I was in class. Dani giggled "Surprise" and Lexi wrapped herself around me then kissed my breath away.
Apparently she was pretty serious about the whole boyfriend thing.
Moments later the football players all high-fived me and said "DUDE" on the way out, followed by two of the cheerleaders who each hugged me and said "BYE" as they left. The other cheerleader was introduced as Holly, a stunning 6' redhead with a body as close to perfect as Dani and Lexi. With long red hair and an electric smile, I imagined her getting anything she wanted from life. Holly came closer, I could feel the heat coming off her body, and I was getting hard and prayed none of them noticed. Holly touched my face and said "It's your lucky day handsome. You get a blonde, a brunette and a redhead". Lexi had black hair, but why quibble? Holly continued "You're lucky because besides Dani and Lexi, you have me now because I'm moving in too".
Everything went dark. I fainted dead to the floor.
I opened my eyes in a dark room and felt something warm against me. I shifted and Lexi moved to snuggle closer with a deep sigh. I was in the bedroom from yesterday, mine now apparently, and Lexi was in bed with me, cuddled against me sleeping. Where do I start? I could see my stuff all around the room, this was really happening. I sighed then stared at Lexi's cheer uniform on the floor next to the bed. Oh boy. The clock showed 1:34pm so I wasn't sure why it was so dark. Maybe dark colored curtains? Oh yeah, I was also rock hard thanks to the warm cheerleader in bed with me.
I lay there overthinking because it's what I do best.
Even if this whole thing with ‘dating' me was a prank or some kind of experiment, clearly the girls were serious about it and all in because when they weren't stalking me or kissing me, they had moved my stuff in without even asking me. My mom says I get in my own way and I might never meet a nice girl because I would be too busy debunking her interest. That means doubting she likes me for the six pack crowd. Yeah, okay, maybe I am rude. Sorry. So I wasn't sure what was going on, but a part of me insisted it was exactly what it seemed. They wanted a roommate, somehow found me interesting, were used to getting whatever they wanted, and at least for now that was me. The problem is I didn't want to admit my lack of experience with girls and my norm of pushing people away and being by myself was not going to help me with these flirty cheerleaders who were used to getting what they wanted. I had to know, so I eased the covers down and up... and lost my breath. MY GOD. Lexi's body was amazing. She was almost naked, wearing only tiny pink panties and a matching tight pink bra. I was overwhelmed with feelings because I wanted to have sex, I just never got the chance and always got nervous. Katie and I had talked it to death but never actually took the steps past kissing and cuddling.
The introverted and anxious part of me wanted to slip out of bed and run, escape, but Dani and apparently Holly were probably lurking somewhere waiting to ambush me. The horny guy part of me wanted to touch Lexi and see her naked, but the fear won out and I just let the covers down and lay there holding Lexi. I closed my eyes and then it was 3:01pm and Lexi was smiling at me. I smiled back and she asked "You're not mad at me are you?" I sighed "No. I'm just not used to all of this. I usually keep to myself and study". Lexi slid her hand across my chest and asked "Do you know you've been hard for like hours?" I inhaled but Lexi touched my face and said "Stop. Don't do that". I stared into Lexi's blue eyes as she said "Just relax and trust me. I know you haven't done stuff but I'll teach you, and we can do it slowly". I just had to analyze and said "So normally, a beautiful, popular girl like you would not associate with a nerdy guy like me". Lexi asked "Why? Because I'm pretty? Because I'm a cheerleader? Or is it because I'm dumb and wouldn't like a smart guy?" I sighed and Lexi huffed "Wow. That's rude".
Oddly, she didn't storm off or even get out of bed. She just held me.
I said "Maybe we can learn from each other". Lexi said "Okay". I asked "Can you teach me how to talk to girls? How to do things?" Lexi purred as she climbed atop me "I sure can". We were kissing and she definitely knew my hard cock was trapped between us because she was grinding her hot crotch against it. Lexi stopped kissing me and asked "What can you teach me?" I thought carefully and said "Refinement". Lexi blinked. She was cute with her hair all over and lusty eyes. I waited until she said "I don't know what that means". I said "People see you as a cheerleader and sports player but they probably don't expect much from you, do they?" Lexi wrinkled her nose and asked "Sports player?" I asked "What is it called?" Lexi rolled her neck, smiled a flirty smile, moved her hips to grind herself against me, and said "Jock I guess". Lexi was already onto other things as she asked "So what do you know?" I said "That's a really broad, non-specific question". Lexi blinked then sighed and said "Ok, for this to work, you have to talk to me like a normal person. Plus, could you at least try to be nice to me?"
I pulled Lexi down and we kissed, she was still working her body trying to entice me. What she didn't know was that my fear and nervousness was struggling against my desire and lust. We parted and again Lexi sat up to straddle me and look down at me with plenty of lust. She asked "Have you had a girlfriend?" I said "Once. Her name was Katie". Lexi said "Okay. Well did you guys do stuff?" I said "We did everything. Movies, concerts, library, beach, hiking, shopping, videogames..." Lexi sighed and said "That's not what I was talking about". Lexi eased off me and said "For this relationship to work, we have to trust each other, and you have to stop trying to get away". I sighed but Lexi said "There's no escape from me Jesse". I was wondering if Lexi was serious when she put her hair back up into a ponytail then said "Lay back and don't think, just relax and enjoy this". I wasn't sure what ‘this' was until Lexi was working at my pants and then pulling at them and my underwear. I was torn between excitement and fear as Lexi's warm hand found my enraged cock and she gasped "Damn. Total jackpot. You're huge babe". I muttered "You're welcome" but Lexi was glassy eyed and seriously distracted... or focused depending on how you look at it.
Lexi stroked the length of my cock a couple of times then bit her lip and said "Hmmm..." She let go of me, slid out of bed, and started fishing through my stuff until she came back with one of my t-shirts and a grin. I got a good look at Lexi's amazing body in nothing but her skimpy pink lingerie and I think I might have gotten harder. Her breasts were large, firm and full. Her nipples were erect and perky, and her panties were visibly moist. Lexi smiled at me as she dropped my t-shirt on my chest, took hold of my cock, then said "We're going to have a barter system babe". I stared at Lexi curiously as she stroked my cock slowly, firmly, and continued smiling at me. Suddenly my mom was in my brain so I asked Lexi "Will you go out with me?" She smirked and asked "What do you think?" I sighed as she laughed "I'm glad you got with the program and all, but I already claimed you either way". Ok then. I tried mom, I tried. Lexi was slowly stroking the length of my cock and it felt great. She said "So bartering. I have this horny tutor who is more interested in hooking up than helping me". I didn't know whether to laugh or cry so I stared at Lexi who said "So I was thinking I can teach you some stuff about girls and some stuff for the bedroom if you help me stay on the cheer team". I said "Lex, couples do that stuff anyways... I think". Lexi sighed "E" and I said "Right. Lexi. Sorry". She said "Lex is a bad guy who hates Superman. I'm Lexi".
HOLY FUCKING A!
Lexi was stroking slowly, and blew me away when she said "I've had a lot of boyfriends but none of them talked like you. My mom said I was never going to meet a nice guy but then I met you". I was getting close and struggling to think about how many ‘a lot of boyfriends' might be when Lexi realized I was near eruption and smiled a happy smile. She startled me when she touched the t-shirt on my chest and said "When you cum, I want you to imagine doing it inside me". I gasped, my cock throbbed, and I exploded all over Lexi, my chest, and the bed. Lexi was gasping "DAMN" as she continued to stroke while my cock twitched and spurted everywhere. It was a mess and Lexi was laughing and whining at the same time. Somehow Lexi had my cum dripping from her chin, on her chest and bra, stomach and legs. I had cum on my shirt, neck and the t-shirt Lexi never got to use. Lexi let go of me and said "Next time warn me babe. I wanted to wait until you were not so nervous, but we need a shower now thanks to you, so you get to see me naked sooner than I planned".
WHAT?
Apparently ‘NO' is not in Lexi's vocabulary as she practically dragged me across the hall to a bathroom and slammed the door just as Holly was asking "What are you guys doing?" Lexi shouted "STAY OUT. HE'S MINE" and Holly said "Whatever". Lexi pushed me towards the shower and unclasped her bra, dropping it into a clothes basket. WOW! Her boobs were just perfect. I was staring hard but Lexi said "Come on. Start the shower babe". I did and turned to see Lexi bare naked and almost fainted. She was clean shaven and her pussy lips seemed to be wet. Maybe from excitement? We got into the shower but it wasn't anything like I imagined, dreamed, or saw in porn. Lexi literally ignored me and washed her hair, her body, and talked about the house. Dani's grandmother charged $400 a month and paid all utilities except streaming services and groceries, so the girls needed a roommate because they didn't have time for jobs with cheer, sports and... oh yeah... classes. Lexi said that with Holly moving in, I only had to pay $100 and help with food since they already had plenty of streaming. I didn't tell Lexi this, but if I told my mom that I was moving in with three cheerleaders, she would probably prepay the ENTIRE rent for the next decade.
More so if she knew Lexi was attempting to catch me up on sex.
I was washed up and bored since Lexi just wanted to talk and wash herself. I didn't exactly expect my first time to be in the shower, but it was kind of a letdown to be in there with Lexi naked and have nothing to show for it. Man, I really can be rude. I'll work on it, I promise. We were drying off when Lexi literally stopped talking mid-sentence and gasped "Oh my God babe, I am so sorry". I was looking around. Sorry for what? What happened? Lexi dropped her towel and poured her naked body against mine and we kissed warmly. Of course my cock started to get hard so she fumbled between us and parked it right against her flaming slit. I couldn't think. Couldn't breathe.
THIS WAS IT!
THIS WAS HAPPENING!
And then it didn't.
Holly was banging on the door shouting for us to hurry up because it was their turn. Their turn for what? A shower I hoped. With my cock pressing against Lexi's wet entrance I begged "I don't want to share, Lexi. It's stressful enough with one gorgeous woman, I can't handle two". Lexi sighed "Three" then kissed me and said "I'll protect you, I promise". I was really horny despite having cum not that long ago and Lexi was so lusty that nearly everything she did excited me. I willed my cock to enter her and the tip pressed against her soft lips as Lexi panted "We need to find someone to distract Holly and Dani". I gasped "There's an entire football team" but Lexi blushed, made a face, then said "Well, the thing is... she's bored with them already". I gasped, my cock pressed an inch into Lexi, she moaned and dug her nails into my back, and I blurted "All of them?" Lexi's eyes rolled back as she begged "Fuck me. Do it. I want you inside me" as Holly barged in and said "Oh Hell no" and literally pulled us apart. Lexi was dizzy, weak legged and glassy eyes as she reached for me. My cock ached and I needed to be inside Lexi as Holly said "Share means share Lexi". Lexi pulled at Holly and it caused me to slip, trip or fall and bang my head against the doorframe.
I woke up with a killer headache, I was thirsty, and Lexi was sitting beside me watching cartoons on a tablet. I stared at the ceiling for a minute and realized I had shorts or something on, maybe underwear. Ok then. I sipped a warm soda from the nightstand then looked at Lexi who was seriously enjoying what turned out to be anime. She was wearing black leggings, a t-shirt, and her hair was down and soft. Man she was beautiful. Lexi gasped "You think I'm beautiful?" We were kissing when I groaned because my head hurt. Lexi said "So I went through your phone and figured out that you call and text Dennis and Carl the most. I wasn't snooping, I swear". I asked "And?" Lexi laughed "Dennis seems nice for a band geek. It doesn't matter though because Holly literally dragged him to her bedroom hours ago and they haven't come out since". Oh. Wow. You're welcome Dennis, cross virginity off your list I would guess. I didn't know whether to laugh or cry about everything so I asked "Are you really my girlfriend?" Lexi sighed then said "You know, people who complain as much as you do usually end up with nothing". I said "Sorry" and Lexi said "It's okay. Just stop making me feel worthless. Please?"
We kissed and then Lexi said "So I think we should talk about earlier". I froze. Earlier? Hours ago? I looked at the clock. 7:17. FUCK. I missed both my afternoon classes. I haven't missed a class since 5th grade. Lexi asked "Are you okay?" I asked "By any chance do you know where my phone is? Did my mom call?" Lexi smiled and said "She is so nice. She said to tell you she's never been happier. I accidentally sent her a bikini picture when she asked to see what I looked like, but she said to tell you that you're a lucky guy". I wanted to crawl into a hole and die. She sent my mom a bikini picture? I sighed and said "I know I'm lucky. You're off the charts in every possible way". Lexi blinked, blushed, then said "So we can discuss your mom in a minute. You flattering me reminds me about earlier. You were inside me Jesse. Maybe only a little bit and not for long, but you were inside me babe". I swallowed but Lexi said "No. Don't do that. Don't pretend you didn't like it or that you don't want it to happen. I deserve respect. I might be dumb but I'm not stupid". I sighed and said "You're not dumb or stupid Lex... uh... Lexi. You just think about other things than constant studying". Lexi sighed "You're so nice to me sometimes". I asked "Sometimes?" Lexi said "Well yeah. Other times you say rude stuff and make jokes, but mostly you're nice to me".
I said "I have never slept this much ever. Between passing out and hitting my head, I might have wasted half the day asleep". Lexi asked "Are you hungry babe?" I was but I looked at the closed bedroom door and muttered "Uhhh...". Lexi said "Oh, don't worry. We have an understanding now. Holly, has a new toy, your friend Dennis, and Dani started dating the football team from across town". I gasped "The entire team?" Lexi shrugged "At some point yeah". We went out to the kitchen, must be Lexi dressed me when I was out cold, because I had on shorts, a t-shirt and socks. We had sandwiches and watched STAR TREK STRANGE NEW WORLDS from the PARAMOUNT PLUS app. Lexi didn't care about what we watched, she just wanted to snuggle. I asked "Are you affectionate or am I just lucky?" Lexi said "Well, what are you really asking me?" I raised an eyebrow and said "I just notice that you like to snuggle". Lexi sighed and asked "Are you really working on being nice and not rude?" I nodded and Lexi said "Okay. Well, I really like sex. Not as much as Dani. She's had like a million boyfriends. I'm proud to say I have only had 37 boyfriends including you". I gasped "37?" Lexi whined "You promised". I held her even though she was mad and said "I don't know how many is normal, so who am I to judge?"
Lexi huffed a couple of times then said "You sure can be a jerk. You're lucky I like you". I said "That's absolutely true". Lexi stared at me for a long moment then said "Fine mister jerk. I like sex and can't wait until we have it, but I know you don't have a lot of experience so I'm trying to slow down and be what I think you want". I swallowed and said "I'm sorry Lexi, I really am". She huffed "My mom says in order to keep a nice guy like you interested I have to do more than take my clothes off. I have to get to know you and that's new to me". I closed my eyes. How is it I could find the one slutty cheerleader that's hotter than fire and just wants to be loved? I kissed Lexi softly then said "I promise to treat you like a lady and like a friend and I will never break a promise". Lexi asked "Can we try stuff until you're ready?" I wasn't certain what else we could try. We had already been naked together, taken a shower, she jerked me off and I was sort of inside her. What was left? Dani appeared and I gasped. Her black lingerie left little to the imagination and she had a really nice body.
Lexi said "It's okay to stare, she wants you to". I blinked and Lexi asked "You do realize women don't accidentally wear lingerie, short skirts, bikinis and such. If we show off our body, it's because we want the attention". I looked at Dani who is really hot, then looked at Lexi and asked "So right now in leggings and a shirt?" She shrugged and said "Most likely we'll be naked at bedtime and I know for a fact I have your attention, so why not?" Good point. Dani said "Our coach says cheer uniforms are skimpy because the teams want fans to look at us in case the team is doing bad plus fans spend more if they're distracted". WOW! How about that? Dani said "I'm bored. Can I play with your toy for a while?" I gasped and Lexi shouted "No. He's not a toy, he's my boyfriend and I actually like him". Dani gasped and just left the room. Not a word, just left. I looked at Lexi and asked "Can I ask you something?" She asked "Is it going to be rude?" I sighed "I hope not". Lexi smiled, kissed me softly, then said "Shoot". I asked "What were your initial plans for me?" Lexi sighed then said "To have some fun and then move on. You were definitely getting laid, but you're just too nice to use like that so I'm slowing down and allowing feelings".
WOW. Just wow.
We went into the bedroom and Lexi started fussing around and I realized what she was doing and helped her unpack and put away my stuff. As strange as the whole situation was, the girls had somehow arranged and managed to get all of my stuff from my dorm room to here in a short period of time. It was impressive in a stalkerish kind of way. Lexi asked "Can I be honest? I said "Always" and Lexi said "I'm trying to keep busy because I really want to mess around but I'm trying to be good but it's hard because I only know how to be naughty". I froze exactly where I was standing. What do you even say to that? The whole situation was surreal, but when a nerdy guy ends up with a gorgeous athletic cheerleader who wants to fuck him, it kind of makes birthdays and Christmas seem boring. The dumbest question possible popped into my head so I asked "What happens afterwards?" Lexi just kept unpacking, folding, and putting away as she said "Well. If I like the guy I keep seeing him until things get stale or he acts like a jerk. In your case I think I might break my record for relationship length because I've never dated anyone like you and I actually like you when you're not being rude". Apparently Lexi didn't know about things like run-on sentences and proper grammar, but all I had to do was look at her and forget what I was worrying about.
I asked her "So what is your record? Your longest relationship?" Lexi smiled proudly and said "Four weeks". I had to sit down. Four weeks? And she was proud of it? Holly came in naked and my heart stopped. Jesus there was a God after all. Holy fucking hotness, it's true what they say about redheads. I was drooling as Lexi said "You did that on purpose coming in here naked. Now look at him?" I was delirious, no offense to Lexi who is an 11 on the 10 scale, but Holly wasn't hot, she WAS heat! The worst, and best part was Holly stood so that I could look right at her wet, pink lips and stare at her slit. Oh my God I wanted so bad to taste her, to touch her, to be inside her. Holly moaned "You don't even have to ask" and was all over me like a January blizzard. I swear on my life and all that I care for it happened so fast that I still can't believe it. Holly pounced on me, pulled at my shorts, grabbed my hard cock, and literally stuffed me inside her volcanic pussy. Oh my God I was finally inside a woman, not a little like with Lexi earlier, but actually all the way inside.
Lexi was screaming and pulling at Holly, pulling at me, but I had no resistance left and began to stroke inside Holly as she begged "FUCK ME. FUCK ME HARD". I stroked three, four, maybe five times and was well on my way to bliss when Lexi finally separated us and slapped Holly so hard it sounded like a gunshot. Holly rushed out of the room and just when I thought Lexi was going to flip, she cuddled me and asked "Are you okay babe? I know that was a lot. I promise to give you anything you want and do anything with you, but it has to be with me, not them, okay?" I nodded and begged "I'm so sorry Lexi, I never had a chance". I wasn't lying either. Dani came into the room and asked "What happened? Holly just ran into her room naked and she was crying". Then Dani spotted my erection and said "WHOA". Lexi said "Back off. He's mine and I'm not joking either". Dani pushed past Lexi's arms and just like that my cock was in her mouth. She got three or four deep sucks before Lexi pulled her off me but it was too late. Being hard around Lexi, briefly fucking Holly, and then Dani sucking me was too much and I exploded right in Danielle's face. She laughed as her hands found my cock and rubbed until I had spurted in her hair and face three or four times.
Lexi let go of me and left the room crying as Dani said "Thank you" and also left. I wiped up with a t-shirt since that's what Lexi showed me to do, pulled my shorts back up, and went to find Lexi. Holly was coming out of her room, stopped, and said "I'm sorry. I'm not mad at you and I'm sorry for teasing you in front of Lexi". I was thinking what to say when Holly glanced around, then put her lips to my ear and whispered "You will be back inside me soon, real soon, and we will finish what you started". I gasped as Holly turned and left the house, slamming the front door in the process. What I started? How was it my fault? Dani came out of the other bathroom with her hair back in a wet ponytail, smiled at me, and said "Thank you" again as she waved then left also. Why was she thanking me for cumming in her face? Was that a thing with some girls? I couldn't find Lexi and since Holly and Dani were gone, I literally searched the entire house. Then I realized I didn't know her last name, we weren't friends on social media, and I didn't even have her phone number. Wow, and I was the one wondering if her feelings for me were real. If dating me was real or some kind of prank.
I called Dennis who thanked me a dozen times, then asked how I got connected with three horny cheerleaders. I told him "I just came by responding to a roommate wanted ad" and he laughed, then said "No, seriously?" I waited and then he said "Oh, you're not joking". I asked "Where are you?" Dennis said "Holly wanted to have dinner. I seriously thought it was a one and done like THE USOS but out of nowhere she called me a few minutes ago and said she changed her mind and wanted to see me". I said "You're welcome" but Dennis said "Oh I already know about that. She thought it was funny to tell me while I was fucking her that she was going to do you whether Lexi liked it or not. She just texted me about your short visit". Dennis was laughing and repeating ‘short visit' until I said "Your only job Dennis is to keep fucking her so I don't lose Lexi. Dani and Holly are no joke. I didn't think cheer sluts existed outside of cheesy movies but these two are the real deal". Dennis sighed as I chuckled "Holly" and he huffed "What's so funny?" I asked "What was that story you used to tell me about? The one with the redhead named Holly who deserved better and worked in a bikini store?" Dennis laughed "ALICIA AND THE BIKINI STORE. Yeah, that clown jwdoney left everyone hanging after like 57 parts, Amber never got any, and then after a ridiculous dream sequence where the entire story was a dream, he left us hanging again with HOLLY AND JOSH".
I said "Dennis, you realize you're talking about erotica? It's a story bro, it's not real". Dennis shouted "HOLLY IS REAL TO ME!" We laughed until Dennis said "Shit, my Holly heard me and now she wants to do it". I said "You could have worse problems" and we hung up. I still didn't know where Lexi was or how to find her... or call her. I still couldn't believe they had moved me in and I didn't have to go back to the dorm again. I went outside and there she was, sitting on the lawn crying and ripping up handfuls of grass. I held her and she asked "You... you're not mad?" I said "Fuck no, you scared me. I just found you and I don't want to lose you". Lexi looked at me with teary eyes and asked "Before I kiss you, will you promise me something?" I said "Anything" and Lexi smiled then said "Stop all the doubting and second guessing. I get that you're a nerd, I'm a jock and a cheerleader, and you think I'm so hot, but we're just two people. I'm sick of casual sex and you need to get some, so why can't we just be happy and stop worrying?" It mostly made sense. I held Lexi and said "I was concerned at first, but I want this Lexi". She seemed sad, looked at the grass, then asked...
"But now that you've had a taste of Holly and Dani, do you still want me?"
... absolutely to be continued
|
Note from the webmaster: authors always appreciate feedback about their stories, so by all means write the author a note if you liked the story! The author of this story: jwdoney |